Free standard shipping on orders over $100

Hand-crafted sandals, made in America

A portion of each sale goes to St. Jude Children's Research Hospital

Your cart

Your cart is empty

How to Break in Leather Sandals

How to Break in Leather Sandals: Complete Guide to Breaking in Leather Flip Flops

Stepping into a new pair of leather sandals holds the promise of comfort and style, but breaking them in can take a while, and isn’t always the smoothest process. Learning how to break in leather sandals is a journey of patience and care, but it makes your new sandals even better!

In this guide, we’ll explain everything you need to know about breaking in leather sandals. We’ll show you how to mold these sandals to your feet without suffering from painful blisters, allowing you to stride with confidence and comfort. 

We’ll also give you some important care tips for looking after your leather sandals once you’ve broken them in, preserving your investment and keeping your sandals in top condition, even after many miles and many years.

Looking for a new pair of premium, American made sandals? You’ve come to the right place! Browse our collection of top-rated Southern Polished leather sandals, designed and made right here in the US from full-grain leather hides, tanned in Milwaukee. 

Why Breaking in Leather Sandals is Necessary

First of all, why do you need to learn how to break in leather sandals? While leather sandals exude timeless elegance and quality craftsmanship, their initial stiffness can pose discomfort. Here’s how breaking in new leather sandals can make a big difference. 

Understanding Leather’s Unique Qualities

Leather, known for its durability and flexibility, holds a character unlike any other material. However, fresh leather sandals often arrive stiff, owing to their untouched, pristine state. The natural fibers in leather need time to yield and adapt to the contours of your feet. 

By breaking them in, you encourage the leather to relax, gradually conforming to the unique curves and movements of your foot anatomy. This process not only enhances comfort but also enhances the longevity of your sandals, creating a personalized fit that improves over time.

Preventing Foot Pain and Discomfort

Stiff, unyielding leather sandals can initially lead to discomfort, causing blisters or abrasions as they rub against sensitive areas of your feet. Learning how to break in leather flip flops helps prevent such discomfort by softening the leather and minimizing friction. 

By taking the time and gradually breaking in leather flip flops, you can significantly reduce the risk of developing painful blisters or sore spots, ensuring that your sandals become a reliable, comfortable companion for everyday wear.

The Anatomy of Leather Sandals

When learning how to break in leather sandals, understanding their anatomy is key. Let’s take a look at the different components of leather sandals and which areas require breaking in.

Identifying Key Areas That Require Breaking In

Breaking in leather sandals involves identifying specific areas that initially don’t conform to your feet's shape. Common trouble spots include the toe strap, over-foot straps, and the footbed. 

Straps, especially those around the ankle or instep, can rub against the skin, leading to potential blisters. The footbed, although designed for support, might feel stiff and rigid at first. Once you’ve identified these areas, breaking in leather flip flops is easier. 

Materials Matter

The quality and type of materials used in crafting leather sandals significantly impact their comfort and break-in process. High-grade leather, such as full-grain or top-grain leather, tends to be more durable and pliable, easing the breaking-in phase. 

The footbed material, often composed of cork, EVA foam, or leather, plays a crucial role in comfort and adaptability. In general, a leather footbed is easier and faster to break in, increasing your comfort and letting you wear your new leather sandals for longer with each passing day.

How to Break in Leather Sandals to Avoid Blisters and Discomfort

If your sandals are giving you blisters or causing you pain, they aren’t doing their job. Here’s how to break in leather sandals without sacrificing your comfort levels, allowing you to enjoy and appreciate your sandals without constantly reaching for the bandaids. 

Wearing Them In Gradually Around the House

Before you show off your new sandals to the world, wear them for short periods indoors. This allows your feet to get used to the sandals' shape. By gradually breaking in leather sandals, you’re minimizing friction and reducing the chance of developing blisters while the leather adapts to your feet.

Using Leather Conditioners

A leather conditioner can help to loosen the fibers, making the leather more supple and speeding up the process of breaking in leather sandals.

Look for leather conditioners specially formulated for softening and nourishing the leather. Apply these conditioners sparingly on the straps and footbed, allowing the leather to absorb the product gradually. 

Heat and Movement

Harness the power of heat and movement to expedite the breaking-in process. Use a hairdryer on low heat to warm specific areas of the sandals, such as straps or the toe thong, for a few minutes. 

Then, flex and move those sections to encourage the softened leather to mold to your feet's contours. This technique helps in loosening the tight spots for a quicker adaptation.

Protecting Your Feet

Prioritize your comfort when breaking in leather sandals. Apply bandaids on areas prone to friction, such as the heel or sides of your feet. This acts as a protective barrier, minimizing the risk of blisters while allowing you to continue wearing your sandals comfortably.

How Long Does it Take to Break in New Leather Sandals?

So, how long does breaking in leather sandals take? It’s different for each pair of sandals, but here’s an idea of what you can expect when it comes to the time it takes for breaking in new leather sandals. 

Factors That Affect Break-In Time

Several factors influence the time required to break in new leather sandals. The type and quality of leather play a significant role; softer, more pliable leather tends to conform more quickly than stiffer varieties. 

The design complexity and the sandals' construction, including the number of straps and the materials used for the footbed, can also impact the break-in period. Your foot shape and sensitivity also affect how long it takes for your sandals to become comfortable.

Typical Timeframes

The time needed to break in leather sandals can range from a few days to a few weeks. Generally, wearing the sandals for short periods daily and gradually increasing the duration helps speed up the process. 

Sometimes, softer leather sandals might begin to feel comfortable within a week of consistent wear. The best leather sandals, made from high-quality leather, tend to break in faster,  especially if aided by a leather conditioner.

For sandals made from stiffer or thicker leather, or those with intricate designs, the breaking-in phase might take a bit longer - up to a few weeks. Patience is key during this period, as rushing the process can cause blisters and irritation if you try to wear your sandals for too long.

Caring for Your Sandals Post-Break-In

Learning how to break in leather flip flops is just the first step in caring for your new sandals. Here are some tips for keeping your leather sandals in peak condition, preserving your investment for years to come. 

First of all, learn how to clean leather sandals properly, and when to do it. Make sure you follow any specific cleaning tips or instructions provided by the sandal manufacturer, as not all leather products require the same care. 

Store your leather sandals out of the sun to prevent cracking, protect them from prolonged exposure to moisture, try not to wear them if it’s raining, and use a leather conditioner to protect your sandals long-term.

Final Thoughts on How to Break in Leather Sandals

There you have it! Breaking in new leather sandals is a process you have to go through with every new pair of sandals, but it doesn’t need to be painful as long as you stay patient, break in your sandals properly, and care for them along the way. 

Starting with high-quality leather is a great way to ensure your newly broken in sandals stand the test of time. At Southern Polished, we use premium full-grain leather hides and the age-old process of vegetable tanning to create a beautiful, natural finish. 

Our men’s leather sandals just get better with age. They become more comfortable, develop a beautiful patina, and soften beautifully over time - these sandals will still be your favorites after many long years of wear. And that’s exactly how we designed them - to last!

Our beautiful southern bags are made from the same, premium, full-grain leather as our shoes. By combining tried-and-true techniques with contemporary designs, we’ve created gorgeous leather products that are built to last and become more unique with every passing day.

Now that you know how to break in leather flip flops, treat yourself to the best quality leather sandals - shop Southern Polished today! 

Previous post
Next post

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published